Can You Sue Someone for Emotional Distress in Texas?

If someone’s negligence has caused you serious mental harm, you may be curious about pursuing a lawsuit. While Texas law does allow recovery for emotional distress in certain situations, these cases tend to be much more complicated than people expect. There’s no doubt that emotional harm can be just as debilitating as a physical injury, but the courts require a strong legal basis for an emotional distress lawsuit. In most cases, emotional distress damages are paid out as part of a larger personal injury claim, not their own separate claim.

Reaching out to a personal injury attorney is your next step if you’ve suffered mental distress because of another person’s actions and you’re curious about your rights. Call Pat Maloney: Accident & Injury Attorney now to discuss your case.

What counts as emotional distress under Texas law?

In a legal sense, emotional distress refers to intense psychological suffering caused by another person’s actions. Emotional distress can manifest in a number of ways, including:

  • Anxiety
  • Depression
  • Post-traumatic stress disorder
  • Panic or anxiety attacks
  • Sleep disturbances (including sleeping too much or too little)
  • Fear
  • Loss of enjoyment of life
  • Anguish that interferes with daily activities and obligations

It’s important to note that not all stressful or emotionally painful experiences count as emotional distress. Courts look for evidence of the nature, duration and severity of serious emotional harm, rather than mere frustration, embarrassment and shame.

Can you sue someone for emotional distress in Texas?

Sometimes, you can sue someone for emotional distress in Texas, but there are significant limitations. To start, Texas does not generally recognize standalone lawsuits for emotional distress. In the absence of a larger injury, you may not be able to file a lawsuit based on emotional suffering caused by someone else’s negligence and carelessness. Emotional distress damages are usually only awarded when they’re linked to another legal claim like:

In these situations, the emotional distress is a result of the accident or issue leading to the initial claim—not a claim in and of itself. Negligent infliction of emotional distress is the term used for harm caused by another person’s negligence, but it is not recognized in Texas as an independent cause of action. One exception is for qualifying bystanders who are near the scene and contemporaneously perceive a close family member being traumatically, severely, or fatally injured. This is known as the bystander exception. Other circumstances in which mental anguish damages may be recoverable include certain privacy and defamation claims.

When can an emotional distress lawsuit succeed in Texas?

While many emotional distress claims require a corresponding physical injury to succeed, there are limited cases where you can sue for emotional distress. Intentional infliction of emotional distress applies when someone intentionally or recklessly causes severe emotional suffering.

Succeeding with this type of claim generally means showing that no other recognized legal claim addresses the conduct and that the defendant engaged in extreme and outrageous conduct that intentionally or recklessly caused you severe emotional suffering. This is a tough legal bar to clear, as it’s reserved for behavior that goes beyond all possible bounds of decency. Examples may include severe harassment, credible threats of violence, egregious abuse of authority, and shocking misconduct.

Furthermore, you must be able to prove that the situation caused severe emotional distress. This goes far beyond embarrassment, anger, sadness, and other negative emotions you may experience. Your mental distress must be so severe that no reasonable person could be expected to endure it.

That means that these types of claims are difficult to succeed with in two different ways. Not only must you prove that the other party’s conduct was egregious and outrageous, but you also have to demonstrate the severity and consequences of your emotional distress.

Emotional distress as part of a personal injury claim

If you are seeking compensation for a personal injury—for example, a slip and fall or car accident—you may be able to receive additional compensation for your emotional distress. It’s not uncommon for accidents or assaults to cause anxiety, PTSD, sleep disturbances, or depression. In this scenario, it’s important to discuss how your mental health has been affected with your personal injury attorney.

How to prove emotional distress

Evidence is crucial for any personal injury case, but it can be difficult to obtain and verify in claims of emotional distress. Emotional injuries can’t be seen on diagnostic imaging the way many physical injuries can, which makes them vulnerable to insurance companies’ claims of falsification or exaggeration. Luckily, there are many forms of evidence that can support your claims of emotional distress:

  • Medical records
  • Therapy and counseling records
  • Mental health evaluations
  • Prescription records
  • Records and testimony from mental health professionals
  • Personal journals showing your symptoms
  • Employment records showing how your distress has impacted your work

Your evidence should be strong, and it should come from multiple sources. This makes it harder for the insurance company to challenge it, and it makes it far easier to prove the extent of your suffering.

What is an emotional distress lawsuit worth?

Unfortunately, there’s no cut-and-dried answer to this question. There are many factors that come into play when negotiating or awarding compensation for emotional distress, including the severity of the emotional harm, treatment needed, impact on employment, impact on daily life, and the strength of your evidence.

Every single case is different, and even two people with similar cases may have dramatically different outcomes. Online settlement calculators and generalized payout estimates can be particularly unreliable for claims involving emotional distress, simply due to the wide number of factors involved.

Take the first step in your claim with Pat Maloney: Accident & Injury Attorney

Whether you want to take legal action after a serious accident or you’re considering a lawsuit for intentional infliction of emotional distress, your next step is talking to a personal injury lawyer. Let’s discuss your options now. Just call us or get in touch with us online.